Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

When Harry Met Sally

Culinary Movie Night Guide

Difficulty Level: Easy

Table Of Contents

Equipment

Here is a list (with links) of all the equipment and decorations I used for my When Harry Met Sally Culinary Experience. I would be incredibly grateful if you used my links. I will make a little commission, and that would really help with the cost of the website and related expenses. You can find my full Amazon List here!

Fall Leaf Decorations

Tips
  1. Personalizing the Menu– When planning your menu for your movie night, don’t feel pressured to serve exactly what I chose to serve. Feel free to remove/add/replace dishes so it makes sense for you and your guests. I’ve included an editable menu in this guide to make it your own!
  2. Managing Your Time– These movie nights can take a lot of time to prepare, especially if you plan on doing everything yourself. If you are planning a culinary movie night with a group, I suggest doing a potluck style. Have each person contribute a dish or two, and it’ll be very manageable. If you are planning on preparing everything yourself, here are some things I’ve learned while doing these often:
    • Make A To-Do List– I can’t stress this enough! It’s very easy to forget simple things like opening a bottle of prosecco before you start the movie so you aren’t fumbling with the seal before serving. I have done this so many times! Your to-do list should include absolutely everything you need to do leading up to pressing play.
    • Start Early– I learned this after a few very long days of trying to cook, prepare, and host all on the same day. Anything that can be done in advance should be done during the days leading up to the movie night. Some examples include pre-mixing cocktails, making desserts and other foods like soup that hold up well in the refrigerator, and pre-making any handmade decorations. Hosting is stressful enough without having to make a multi-course meal in one day, so get as much done as possible before.
    • No Pausing– The question I get asked the most is “Do you pause the movie to bring out the next dish?”. It’s important to me that I don’t disrupt the flow of the movie, so I do not pause. It’s also important to me to enjoy the movie with my guests. Setting up everything I need before the movie helps me bring out each dish efficiently. The setup usually includes plating each dish and storing it in the refrigerator, so all I have to do is quickly microwave it before serving. I set out any garnish or decoration on my kitchen counter so it’s easily accessible. I even pour the cocktails into their cups and store them in the refrigerator, so all I have to do is add ice and any finishing touches before serving. Always think about how you can do the bare minimum during the film. I always include the setup in my to-do list as well, so I don’t forget about any aspect of the preparation.
    • Optional– If your budget permits, I recommend ordering food that you may not be confident in cooking or food that may take a lot of time to cook. I do this occasionally, and it helps cut down the preparation time and supports local businesses. Win Win!
  3. Decorations- Have fun and decorate your space and serving tray! Add elements from the theme of the movie, but make a budget and stick to it! I usually use things I already own because these movie nights are DIY, and I don’t need to spend a fortune to make it fun. If I do buy decorations for the movie night, I try to find cheap or reusable things. If you are curious about some of the things I’ve used during the movie nights, here is a link to my Amazon List. All these items are things I bought with my own money and enjoyed using.
  4. Manage Stress- Culinary Movie Nights are fun and a great way to show your friends and family you love them. Sometimes, things you envision in your head will not come out perfectly. When this happens to me, it can be discouraging and stressful, but the people I do these for have NEVER expressed anything but appreciation. Go easy on yourself and remember that your guests are just happy to be there and to experience something you put so much thought and time into making.
Menu

I have created a free, editable, and printable menu for all the dishes I served for this Culinary Movie Night! Feel free to change it to what will work for you and your guests.

Click Here

Cues

These are the cues I used during the movie night so I knew when I had to get the next dish ready to serve.

Please note: Each cue describes a scene that happens a few minutes before I have to serve the dish. It does not describe the scene the dish is based on. Some people get confused with that, so I thought I should specify. Because the cues only give you a few minutes to prepare the dish, it’s very important to have everything cooked and set up before the film starts. Review the “Tips” section above for ways to make this seamless.

I often get asked why I don’t use time stamps to keep track of when to serve the next dish and the simple answer is, I don’t find those helpful. If I used timestamps, I would have to have a separate timer going or keep disrupting the movie to check the timestamp. It makes much more sense to have cues to indicate when the next scene is about to happen. This allows me to enjoy watching the film with my guests.

Below is the link to the cues I used. This document is editable, so you can make updates if you decide to take out or change dishes.

Click Here!

Recipes
Grapes Of Wrath

When Harry is eating grapes in the car, I wanted to serve something more than just grapes so I also served some red wine to start off our date night 🙂

Also Harry and Sally disliked each other when they first met so I thought this was a cute name. LOL

A la “High Maintenance”

Apple Pie Recipe

A la mode usually means served with vanilla ice cream but Sally wanted strawberry so I served my apple pie with strawberry ice cream too.

Picky Peking Duck

I personally ordered this dish from a local restaurant but here is a recipe if you want to make it yourself! 🙂

Peking Duck Recipe

Paprikash & Pecan Pie

Chicken Paprikash Recipe

Mini Pecan Pie Recipe

Ingredients:

Mini pie crusts

1 cup of sugar

3 tablespoons of brown sugar

1/2 teaspoon of salt

1 cup of light corn syrup

A dash of vanilla extract

1/3 cup of melted butter

3 eggs

1 and 1/2 cups of chopped pecans

Whole pecans to decorate the top

Instructions:

  1. In a large bowl, add sugar, brown sugar, salt, corn syrup, eggs, vanilla, and butter. Mix with an electric hand mixer.
  2. Fold in chopped pecans.
  3. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Spoon the pie filling into the premade pie shells. Make sure not to fill to the top because the pies will expand in the oven.
  4. Add the whole pecans on top of the pies.
  5. Bake in the oven for about 15-20 minutes or until the filling turns a deep brown.
  6. These are great to make ahead and freeze. To reheat, just bake in the oven for about 10 minutes at 350 degrees F.
  7. Serve with some whipped cream on top.
Foodporn

For this dish, I reserved a pastrami sandwich with a deli style coleslaw. I ordered the sandwich from a local deli because pastrami is a WHOLE process to make. Here are the recipes if you want to make it at home.

Pastrami on Rye Recipe– This recipe has a link specifically for the homemade pastrami.

New York Deli Coleslaw Recipe

Quiche of the 80’s

Mini Pesto Quiche Recipe– I didn’t add cheese or chicken to mine but this is essentially the idea. Either ruse pie crust or puff pasty in mini cupcake tins. Then scramble eggs with pesto and bake. It’s super easy and delicious!

Don’t Schmuck It Up

For this dish, I had the hotdogs ready in hot water and a street cart onion already made so I could quickly add it to the hotdog with some mustard. This is the recipe I used for the onions:

Street Cart Onion Recipe

Mr. Right & Mrs. Always Right

Coconut Cake Recipe

Chocolate Sauce Recipe– Or you can use store bought and heat it up before serving.